Discretionary Trader vs System Trader: Understanding Differences and Advantages

When choosing a trading system, traders often face the decision between becoming a Discretionary Trader or a System Trader. However, what are the actual differences between these two types of traders, and which one is more profitable? Let's delve deeper into this topic.

Discretionary Trader

Discretionary Traders use entry and exit methods that rely on criteria that tend to be subjective. They may rely on fundamental or technical analysis, as well as their own intuition in making trading decisions. For example, a Discretionary Trader might use fundamental analysis to determine when to enter or exit the market.

1. Advantages of Discretionary Trader:

• Flexibility: They can react quickly to market changes and sense price movements in real-time.
• Intuition: The ability to read the market and make decisions based on extensive experience and knowledge.
• Control: They have full control over every trading decision made.

2. Disadvantages of Discretionary Trader:

• Subjectivity: Trading decisions are often based on subjective interpretations, which can lead to errors and losses.
• Emotions: Being directly involved in market rhythms can trigger emotions that may disrupt rational decision-making.

System Trader

System Traders use mechanical trading systems that have been pre-programmed to determine entry and exit levels. They rely on objectively predetermined rules in making trading decisions. For example, a System Trader might use a trading strategy programmed into software.

1. Advantages of System Trader:

• Objectivity: Trading decisions are based on predefined rules, reducing the risk of human error.
• Automation: The ability to trade automatically, allowing traders to save time and energy.
• Consistency: Consistency in applying trading rules, reducing fluctuations in trading results.

2. Disadvantages of System Trader:

• Limitations: Trading systems may not be able to adapt well to changing market conditions.
• Dependence on Software: The success of trading systems heavily relies on the reliability of the software used.

The choice between becoming a Discretionary Trader or a System Trader depends on personal preferences, trading styles, and individual trader situations. The key is to understand the strengths and weaknesses of each type of trader, and to implement good risk management to reduce the likelihood of losses. By understanding trading strategies that align with your personality and needs, you can increase the chances of success in trading.

Share: